West Bend, Wi – A torn $50 bill, a phone number and a little help from the past brought two former sweethearts back together. Forty-three years after they first dated, Tierney Affeldt and Michael Busalacchi made their relationship official Friday, November 13, 2026, in a place that holds a special meaning for them both: the Goodwill Store & Donation Center in West Bend, Wi.

For Tierney, Goodwill was more than a workplace. She spent 12 years with the organization, working her way up to retail supervisor before retiring in February.
“I spent 26 years at home raising my family. When I rejoined the workforce, Goodwill gave me the opportunity to build a career,” says Tierney. “Over the years, I connected so much with the people at Goodwill. We’re just family.”
That connection became even more meaningful in April 2023 when Michael walked into the store looking for a second chance with someone he had dated back in 1980.

Michael wasn’t working up the courage to ask Tierney out in person. Instead, he left a cashier a $50 bill torn in half, with his phone number written on it, hoping the message would make its way to her.

The next day, Tierney received a message that read, “someone from your past wants you to call them.”

She wasn’t sure who it could be, but a look at store surveillance footage helped solve the mystery.
“My manager and I looked back at footage, and I recognized him right away.”
Tierney called Michael, and the two picked up where they had left off decades earlier. That first reunion turned into a four-hour lunch and a renewed romance.
“The butterflies came back. There was always love. We were just too young at the time to realize.”
When the couple decided to get married, Tierney knew exactly where she wanted the ceremony. The Goodwill store was where Michael had walked back into her life, and it was also where she had built lasting friendships over the years.
On November 13, those friends became part of the wedding celebration. Kevin Carsner, a Goodwill employee of more than 20 years, walked Tierney down the aisle. Court Commissioner William Alderson performed the ceremony, and Michael’s 96-year-old aunt served as a witness.
“It was perfect. Everyone who works there is part of my family, and it means so much to me to give back to Goodwill by having my wedding there.”

Jessi Gonzalez-Moore, Tierney’s longtime supervisor, said the staff was happy to be part of the celebration.
“I was equally as excited for Tierney as she was, and our whole team wishes her and Mike happiness for years to come,” says Gonzalez-Moore. “Tierney built strong friendships here, and that’s what made having her wedding at Goodwill so meaningful for us all. We’ve all been supportive and encouraging since that day Mike stopped in.”
The celebration also included a gesture that reflected Tierney’s appreciation for the organization. She donated her wedding decorations back to Goodwill so they could support its mission.
“It’s wonderful how Goodwill helps people get jobs so they can support themselves.”
For Tierney and Michael, a return to a familiar place turned into a new beginning. And the store where their paths crossed again after 43 years became the place where they said, “I do.”










